Feature / Music
Scene Point Blank's Favorites: The Year So Far (August 2009)

Posted pre-2010

Top Five Breakups

1. Nine Inch Nails

The dissolution of Nine Inch Nails was quite an astonishing surprise to most of us. I know I was rather shocked. Trent Reznor had finally escaped from the greedy hands of the record industry and was consistently releasing new material at his leisure, oftentimes for free. Granted, it wasn't his best material, but his new business model to the way that he released music constantly kept things fresh. I know that Reznor isn't done with music just yet; heck there remains a sliver of doubt that Nine Inch Nails is finished. I mean, he did quit Twitter twice this year already?

2. Have Heart

Amongst the biggest hardcore bands in the world, Have Heart's announcement of their eventual breakup towards the year's end sent their fanbase scurrying to messageboards in protest - cheap shot, I know. The worst part about this breakup is that Have Heart was finally beginning to write music that reached beyond the limited one-dimensional style of their early recordings. It'll be interesting to see where the members go on from here.

3. Clouds

The post-Cave In world was an interesting one, to say the least. Each member had their own project, or in some case projects. Of all the branches and offshoots, Clouds seemed to be the most consistent and dependable. They had a solid lineup, released two full-length albums, and toured quite a bit as well. Unfortunately, the band will be going on a hiatus in the near future, as a member is moving away from their center. Fortunately, we have the return of Cave In to console us.

4. Verse

Yes, it's true. Verse broke up. I don't have much to say about this one. Just know it had a huge impact because the band was about to embark on a full U.S. tour with New Found Glory, a tour that caused a lot of controversy with their pre-existing fans. That debate was stupid, it still is. Anyway, it perplexes me why bands break up right around the release of a new album and prior to a tour.

5. Saves the Day

Okay, so they didn't technically break up. But with guitarist David Soloway announcing his departure from the group earlier this year, this leaves vocalist Chris Conley as the only longstanding member of the group. It's been a downward spiral for Saves the Day as the years have passed on, losing members along the way, and the songwriting has suffered as a result. At this point, it's almost worth forgetting to release that last album.

(Michael)

— words by the SPB team

Related features

Cheap Fix

One Question Interviews • July 14, 2025

Cheap Fix SPB: What’s the most MacGyver-esque workaround you’ve made to connect different bits of equipment? Chad Nichols (guitar/vocals): You'd think with a name like Cheap Fix, we'd be all over this question. But I'm the least handy of the band members, so I've got next to nothing. All my … Read more

Mike Huguenor

One Question Interviews / What's That Noise? • July 8, 2025

Mike Huguenor Tell us about the primary guitars you used making Surfing the Web with the Alien? Read more

Scene Point Blank's Favorites: The Year So Far (July 2025)

Music • July 6, 2025

We're halfway through the year: when did that happen?! Luckily for you, SPB is on hand to share the music we've enjoyed most in 2025 thus far. Read on to hear about the records that have made our top list for this year as it stands, and also some bonus … Read more

Shane Herrell: A Tribute

Music • July 6, 2025

Shane Herrell: Rest In Power(pop) (1980-2025) The Rocker I try to live my life with as few regrets as possible. Sadly I never got the chance to hear my friend Shane Herrell karaoke Thin Lizzy’s "The Rocker." As a singing bass player we don’t have enough heroes. It might just … Read more

Unseemlier

One Question Interviews • June 27, 2025

Mike Assatly (Unseemlier - guitar/vocals) SPB: Do you have a preferred model of van for touring? Assatly: Chevy G-20 Gladiator! It was my first van, I got it from my uncle with 115,000 on it. He got rid of it for a new van because it was "old" and would … Read more

More from this section

Scene Point Blank's Favorites: The Year So Far (July 2025)

Music • July 6, 2025

We're halfway through the year: when did that happen?! Luckily for you, SPB is on hand to share the music we've enjoyed most in 2025 thus far. Read on to hear about the records that have made our top list for this year as it stands, and also some bonus … Read more

Shane Herrell: A Tribute

Music • July 6, 2025

Shane Herrell: Rest In Power(pop) (1980-2025) The Rocker I try to live my life with as few regrets as possible. Sadly I never got the chance to hear my friend Shane Herrell karaoke Thin Lizzy’s "The Rocker." As a singing bass player we don’t have enough heroes. It might just … Read more

Caterwaul 2025

Music • May 13, 2025

Each year in late May, the 4-day party and noise-rock festival Caterwaul takes over multiple venues in Minneapolis. It’s a stacked lineup this year, to put it mildly, with each night’s headliners FACS, Young Widows, Naw, Pissed Jeans, and Uniform -- and that’s leaving a ton of other great bands … Read more