Review
Martha
Please Don’t Take Me Back

Dirtnap, Specialist Subject Records (2022) Loren

Martha – Please Don’t Take Me Back cover artwork
Martha – Please Don’t Take Me Back — Dirtnap, Specialist Subject Records, 2022

Martha has been building a name on the DIY scene for quite some time. I know I saw them, probably close to 10 years ago, opening for Toys That Kill or some related band. But they don’t play scrappy punk. They dabble more in power-pop that’s built around tight songwriting chops and melodies that stick with you. Britpop meets the basement scene.

While they have quite the discography already, Please Don’t Take Me Back is my first deep dive review from their catalog. And it has me regretting that I didn’t do this sooner because, not only is the record really good, it’s the kind of songwriting that just gets better on repeat.

“Beat, Perpetual” starts out like a classic pop song, from back when pop music was played with actual instruments. It’s big, catchy, and spoken directly to you, the listener. It has that rock ‘n’ roll swagger, even though it’s really all about the melody instead of the ‘tude. And, while it feels uplifting, let’s just glance back at the album title again, because I think it sets the appropriate mood. This record is upbeat, meaning it’s rhythmically uplifting, but the lyrics are dark once you get past the bouncy veneer. I mean, the second song is called “Every Day The Hope Gets Harder,” which I think succinctly sums up how we all feel since about 2016. Sure, it’s a little dramatic. But this is music that’s meant for singalongs, so it needs to jump to the point.

One of the notable points of this record is that different singers and songwriters all share the spotlight, and they all shine in unique but unified ways. You hear the different voices, but they go together seamlessly. Sometimes there are ‘60s garage rock tones, at others ‘90s quirkiness, all balanced with pop energy, dramatic balladry, and some nicely mixed guitar rock where the solos hit but don’t feel gratuitous. To cherry pick details, “Baby Does Your Heart Sink” is a straight-up pop song, complete with “baby” lyrics, but it doesn’t feel ironic or cute. It just works when paired with the deep rock roots that all come together into Martha’s dark and defiant pop sound.

8.5 / 10Loren • December 21, 2022

Martha – Please Don’t Take Me Back cover artwork
Martha – Please Don’t Take Me Back — Dirtnap, Specialist Subject Records, 2022

Related news

Two songs from trio The Martha’s Vineyard Ferries

Posted in Records on February 16, 2025

Nathan SG (Martha/Onsind) solo 7-inch

Posted in Bands on October 14, 2023

More Martha

Posted in Records on August 21, 2022

Recently-posted album reviews

Painkiller

The Equinox
Tzadik (2025)

Painkiller sees three absolute masters of extreme music join forces. John Zorn of Naked City and a billion other projects, Mick Harris who transcended from Napalm Death drummer to illbient guru with Scorn, and producer extraordinaire Bill Laswell. Their first two records, Guts of a Virgin and Buried Secrets are strange meditations traversing between free-jazz, grindcore and dub. Still hungry … Read more

Dauber

Falling Down
Recess (2025)

The lazy approach would be to call Dauber "ex-Screaming Females," but that barely scratches the surface. If I had to pick one band to namedrop a comparison to, it would be labelmates Night Court. They play a familiar style but with a lot of quirks that set it apart from the genre standard-bearers. It's driving and energetic -- more importantly, … Read more

Aesop Rock

Black Hole Superette
Rhymesayers (2025)

Aesop Rock has a reputation for esoteric and abstract raps. It's certainly an earned reputation, but that background makes it interesting when you peel off the layers of his latest, Black Hole Superette and realize that many of these dense songs are actually about the mundane: walking the dog, cohabitation... hell, even fishkeeping. While there's a lot of day-to-day routine … Read more