Review
Sunny Day Sets Fire
Stranger Remix EP

I Am Sound (2008) Campbell

Sunny Day Sets Fire – Stranger Remix EP cover artwork
Sunny Day Sets Fire – Stranger Remix EP — I Am Sound, 2008

Choosing a band name is a tricky thing. If you choose one that sounds lame, people will write you off before they've even heard you. In this case, if you choose a name that's very close to a band that's already existed, then the listener has to wonder a few things. The listener wonders if Sunny Day Sets Fire just doesn't know of the group in question, or if they just assumed that everyone would be too stupid to see the similarity. And this one doesn't even really make sense. But I realize what a pretentious asshole I look like ranting about a band's name and not their music, so let us digress.

The Stranger Remix EP begins with, you guessed it, the original version of "Stranger." It's a cute indie-pop song with mostly indiscernible instruments save the prominent drums and an echoic guitar. Everything is pretty easy on the ears, but the song is passable; nothing really sets it apart from other groups of the poppy electronica-ish subgenre.

The remaining seven tracks on this EP include three more versions of "Stranger" and a few other remixes of their songs. Some prominent DJs like XXXChange and The Cool Kids lend their tweaking abilities to make Sunny Day Sets Fire's songs more appropriate for a club setting. Some tracks simply amplify the electronica touches of the original songs, but others simply butcher the song, to the point where the DJ must have just laid the original vocals over their own beats. This isn't necessarily a bad thing, but it becomes harder to judge the Stranger Remix EP as a work of Sunny Day Sets Fire.

I'm not sure I really see the point of this EP. The remixes are fine; I'd say they're dance club-worthy. But I don't think they don't mean much if you haven't listened to the group previously. And even if you have, judging by the original version of "Stranger," they're probably not much to write home about either. And this goes beyond my frustration of using the full moniker Sunny Day Sets Fire for every reference because the abbreviation Sunny Day belongs to another group in my mind.

And while I'm at it, I think it's notable that in the at least two years that Sunny Day Sets Fire has been around, they have five official releases. Impressive, right? However, there are only eight different songs that span them. Maybe it's just me, but any musical group that has five releases should have written more than eight songs, to avoid redundancy. Having only the same four songs over three consecutive releases doesn't have much value in my book, and you can call me out on that any day. Or perhaps on a sunny day...

3.0 / 10Campbell • April 21, 2008

Sunny Day Sets Fire – Stranger Remix EP cover artwork
Sunny Day Sets Fire – Stranger Remix EP — I Am Sound, 2008

Recently-posted album reviews

Painkiller

The Great God Pan
Tzadik (2025)

Painkiller, the trio of John Zorn, Bill Laswell, and Mick Harris shows no signs of slowing down. The Great God Pan is their third full-length, since their reunion in 2024, and in many ways it is an unexpected offering. In keeping with their interests in the metaphysical realm, Painkiller find inspiration from the famed Arthur Machen horror novella. Here, the … Read more

Painkiller

The Equinox
Tzadik (2025)

Painkiller sees three absolute masters of extreme music join forces. John Zorn of Naked City and a billion other projects, Mick Harris who transcended from Napalm Death drummer to illbient guru with Scorn, and producer extraordinaire Bill Laswell. Their first two records, Guts of a Virgin and Buried Secrets are strange meditations traversing between free-jazz, grindcore and dub. Still hungry … Read more

Dauber

Falling Down
Dromedary Records, Recess (2025)

The lazy approach would be to call Dauber "ex-Screaming Females," but that barely scratches the surface. If I had to pick one band to namedrop a comparison to, it would be labelmates Night Court. They play a familiar style but with a lot of quirks that set it apart from the genre standard-bearers. It's driving and energetic -- more importantly, … Read more