Feature / Interviews
New Idea Society

Words: Shane • Posted pre-2010

Scene Point Blank: A lot of this project seems to deal with you two learning new recording techniques and the like. How does it feel going into writing a record from a songwriting and producing standpoint at the same time? Do you adapt the songwriting to fit the recording style or vise-versa?

Mike: We attempted to create a record that we would like to listen to. I know this is a standard answer but is true. We took a great deal of time to develop a mood for each song. With our limited technical abilities and lack of understanding of how to properly record a record we were forced to contend with some frustrating evenings, but in the end I think it made for a better record. It will surely make for a much better record next time now that we have smoothed out a lot of the learning curve. I think you will see signs of this in the next solo release by Stephen and in the next NIS.

Stephen: It's been a learning experience for both of us, I think. Oftentimes we'd spend all of our energy trying to figure out the proper method to, say, send effects to be printed onto tape without using a 1/4" input jack on the vocal microphone with the set-up we were using... and after many frustrating delays of trial and error similar this one, the performances were sometimes prone to feeling somewhat stale. We tried our hardest to avoid this coming across in the music, and I think we'll do a better job of it on future recordings we make together.

Scene Point Blank: Since New Idea Society is closer to solo Stephen Brodsky than any of your other projects, do you ever wonder which project you should use a song for?

Stephen: My role in this band is to mutate songs that Mike writes. These tunes are like his little Gremlins, and then I come along and feed them all after midnight.

Scene Point Blank: Now that Cave In is on hiatus, what are your plans for the year? Will we see a bit more of touring from New Idea Society or will you be doing a new solo record?

Stephen: Cave In is in the process of compiling together a disc of some tunes we recorded in 2004 for a summer of 2005 release on Hydra Head... and to kill some boredom, I have assembled a new band to play a bunch of songs that I have been working on in the past year or so. These songs were originally going to be on a solo record, but I have changed my mind to instead create a new band altogether. I already have some amazing players and all we need is a decent name for the group.

Scene Point Blank: John Lennon vs. Paul McCartney vs. George Harrison - citing examples, which wrote the better songs?

Mike: Near as I can all tell they were in a band together... as for solo albums I think "All Things Must Pass" by George is my favorite.

Stephen: Hah hah. I love this argument. Here's the catch - they all did it together. "Dear Prudence" could be the finest Beatles song ever written, and it was ultimately John's, but then Paul lays down the brilliant thumping bass line on the 2nd verse... he might have even played drums on that particular one. What I'm getting at here is that the songs written by the individual members were oftentimes great on their own, but then it was the additional elements provided by the other three members that made their songs AMAZING.

Scene Point Blank: If you could collaborate on a project with one person, who would you choose?

Mike: Well I am going to say Brian Eno (although I am afraid Stephen is going to say the same thing and this will make for a boring answer). I find his approach to songs so stunning. His ability to string together such long strands of thought makes me dizzy. It is like committing a novel to music. The mood and sounds are so inter-twined. His albums can be so concise and conceptually perfect yet also be nice to listen to casually. Dozens of listens will produce dozens of discoveries.

Stephen: Brian Eno, hands down. Last summer, a good friend of mine who works at Caroline sent to me the reissues of his four solo albums as a gift, and these albums became the sound of my day. He is a master at adding very human ingredients to a song, so that one day you'll dreamily be humming along with the fuzzy keyboard line heard in a song's chorus, but then as you wait impatiently in line at the grocery store later in the day, you're head will not only be stuck in that very same part of the song... but you'll be drumming along to the clicky percussion noises in that chorus instead. He provides all kinds of focus points to the listener in his music that neither intrudes nor distracts one from the actual listening experience. This allows for the opportunity to gain multiple sensations or feelings from the music, depending upon one's environment or one's mood.


Scene Point Blank's review of You are Awake or Asleep can be found here.

Interview by Shane.

Layout by Michael.

Images courtesy of New Idea Society and Magic Bullet Records.

Related features

Unseemlier

One Question Interviews • June 27, 2025

Mike Assatly (Unseemlier - guitar/vocals) SPB: Do you have a preferred model of van for touring? Assatly: Chevy G-20 Gladiator! It was my first van, I got it from my uncle with 115,000 on it. He got rid of it for a new van because it was "old" and would … Read more

Dollar Store

One Question Interviews • June 26, 2025

Dave Slaverave (Dollar Store - bass) SPB: This band hits a lot of styles, all kind of overlapping at the same time. How hard was it to find “your sound” when bringing these influences together? Slaverave: Not very hard at all actually. We're all old-ass adults who've soaked in a … Read more

Golden Shitters

One Question Interviews • June 25, 2025

Matt (Golden Shitters) How nervous were you the first time you played a show? My first show was around 2002. I was 15 years old and it was a basement house party in my hometown of Welland, Ontario. I’d just proved myself to my high school buddies by singing The … Read more

Arms Aloft

Interviews • June 23, 2025

Remember Election Day 2024? Maybe you shouldn't. Maybe you've blocked it out. That's fair, but there was one pleasant surprise that day: a new EP from Wisconsin's Arms Aloft. It took a while to claw out of the darkness in November, then Year End 2024 coverage took over the Scene … Read more

Small Steps

One Question Interviews • June 12, 2025

Jeremiah (Small Steps - guitar/vocals) SPB: What song has the best use of whistling? Jeremiah: I feel like the easy answer would be the Bobby McFerrin song "Don't Worry Be Happy". Which is catchy as all get out, but we prefer the road less traveled here in Small Steps. For … Read more

Related news

What's up with New Idea Society

Posted in Bands on February 23, 2019

New Idea Society Post New Songs

Posted in MP3s on December 10, 2009

New Idea Society To Enter Studio

Posted in Records on February 20, 2008

Related reviews

New Idea Society

The World is Bright and Lonely
Exotic Fever (2007)

For The World is Bright and Lonely, New Idea Society's Mike Law walks a fine line between poetry and prose. The lyrical structures are simple and for the most part unchanging, and there is a more simple pattern within it all, almost every line the start of a new thought or idea. But herein lies the genius and creativity that … Read more

New Idea Society

You Are Awake Or Asleep
Magic Bullet (2005)

Cave In has been on hiatus for a couple months now and Stephen Brodsky has decided to not sit still. Rumor has it he is working on a new solo album, there is a video being worked on for his solo stuff, and he finally got around to putting out a New Idea Society full length, a follow-up to their … Read more

More from this section

Arms Aloft

Interviews • June 23, 2025

Remember Election Day 2024? Maybe you shouldn't. Maybe you've blocked it out. That's fair, but there was one pleasant surprise that day: a new EP from Wisconsin's Arms Aloft. It took a while to claw out of the darkness in November, then Year End 2024 coverage took over the Scene … Read more

Ilya Arbatman (Rotary Club)

Book store co-owner

Interviews / Don't Quit Your Day Job • May 13, 2025

There are a lot of misconceptions about the life of a musician. Most musicians have day jobs – and not just to pay the bills. Jobs provide new challenges, personal fulfillment and, yes, some rent or gas money. How an artist spends their time by day will influence the creative … Read more

Chuck Ragan

Fly fishing tour guide

Interviews / Don't Quit Your Day Job • April 14, 2025

How an artist spends their time by day will influence the creative process at night. In Don’t Quit Your Day Job, Scene Point Blank looks at how musicians split their time, and how their careers influence their music (or how their music provides escape). In this edition, we caught up … Read more