Recent reviews

Our latest album reviews, featuring the records we've most enjoyed (or not) over the past few weeks.

Reviews by score
Browse our album reviews according to score: Highest (9.5/10 or more) or Lowest (2/10 or less)

Converge

You Fail Me
Epitaph (2004)

Dear Converge, After giving You Fail Me a listen, the only thing I can even begin to contemplate is: "What the fuck happened here?" I'm truly sorry to say that aside from calculating the distance from where I'm sitting to the Cosi two blocks away (I have a coupon for a free sandwich), this is the only thought that's running through my head at the moment. I'm thinking back to the work you did on 2001's Jane Doe and trying to find some sort of explanation for this record. You guys took intense, metallic hardcore to unprecedented heights. Jane Doe was an almost overwhelmingly cathartic record - like each note was wrenched from your hearts and souls. There was emotion, grit, and more importantly substance. Jane Doe was heavy in so many ways - musically, emotionally - but this new record that you've given me sounds...plodding, boring, homogeneous, and really tired. I know there had to have been a whole lot of blood, sweat, and tears put into that record and probably this one, too. But in all honesty, fellas, I'm not hearing any of these things when I put on You Fail Me. Each song seems to kind of … Read more

Converge

You Fail Me
Epitaph (2004)

"Is You Fail Me better than Jane Doe?" Don't lie, that's what you're wondering and hoping this review will answer. … Read more

The Libertines

The Libertines
Sanctuary (2004)

Pete Doherty is so rock n' roll. Every other day the kid is in rehab, and on the other days … Read more

Mare

Mare
Hydra Head (2004)

Maybe I am blinded by my love for Hydrahead Records, but it seems to me that as of late the … Read more

Green Day

American Idiot
Warner Bros. (2004)

If you know anything about Green Day, it's no big secret that they're Who fans (see: Sweet Children EP - … Read more

Green Day

American Idiot
Warner Bros. (2004)

Like too many of their musical peers, Green Day, the longtime bay area punk/pop heroes, have thrown down their challenge … Read more

Browse our review archives

Review categories

200 Words Or Less

749 reviews

Book Review

42 reviews

Classic Album

25 reviews

Multiple Authors

300 reviews

Review

4864 reviews

Video/DVD Review

19 reviews

One from the archives

The Fiery Furnaces

Blueberry Boat
Sanctuary (2004)

Music as true art begs to be delved deeper into. Controversially classic albums such as Daydream Nation, Zen Arcade, and Kid A warrant very little before much time and myriad repeat listens. On first hearing, albums such as the aforementioned often appear completely impenetrable, inaccessible, and, in some cases, entirely unlistenable; nothing exists to grab the listener instantaneously by the hair and shout "THIS IS BRILLIANT" in his or her face; there is nothing immediate to latch on to; nothing that most can easily wrap their minds around upon first exposure. With patience and an open mind, however, most serious music fans will eventually warm up to these albums, allowing them to toy with (or possibly destroy) conventions, open up worlds, and ultimately change how the listener thinks about music … Read more

More album reviews

Further Seems Forever

Hide Nothing
Tooth & Nail (2004)

With the release of their third album, Further Seems Forever presents us with...you guessed it, another lead singer. The evolution goes as follows: Chris Carraba, Jason Gleason, and now John Bunch (formerly of Sense Field). Overall, this is a pretty impressive roster but unfortunately for fans, it's difficult to remain faithful to the band when each album has a completely … Read more

Björk

Medúlla
Elektra (2004)

Pop music usually isn't something that offers much variety in terms of groundbreaking artistic expression, innovation, and, when it all comes down to it, quality. In the MTV generation of plastic creativity, few dare to venture into the realm of experimentation for fear of losing that ever-so-valuable celebrity clothing line, and dropping off the Top 40 charts. For every Björk, … Read more

Omar A. Rodriguez-Lopez

A Manual Dexterity: Soundtrack Volume 1
GSL (2004)

Fans of the bespectacled Omar of At The Drive-In/Mars Volta fame will already have an idea of how this record will sound thanks to Rodriguez-Lopez's creative and original guitar work in both bands. More notably in The Mars Volta (where Rodriguez wrote most of the songs) his passion for synths, drum machines, strange vocals and heavily effect-laden guitars was documented … Read more

Sahara Hotnights

Kiss & Tell
RCA (2004)

Perhaps the name of Sahara Hotnights singer Maria Andersson's boyfriend rings a bell - Howlin' Pelle Alvmquist of the Hives. Or maybe you just know Sahara Hotnights, because you swear you've seen the name somewhere; that would be the press' fault. Sahara Hotnights has been dubbed "the next big thing" by several sources since the garage band explosion. They all … Read more

Head Automatica

Decadence
Warner Bros. (2004)

It was merely a few years ago that I, a young teenage boy, was sitting in my bedroom watching the Howard Stern show on E!. On this particular episode, as on every particular episode, Stern was giving away a pair of saline boobies to whichever lucky girl would humiliate herself the most. I don't remember the particulars, other than that … Read more

Lights Out

Get Out
Youngblood (2005)

When was the last time you were angry? You're on a computer at the moment, so maybe you have a sticky key that really pisses you off. Or maybe your computer speaks to you in a really sarcastic tone, and you...just...can't....take...it...anymore. At any rate, anybody can relate to anger. Hey...you also like music, I bet. Crucial music you say? Well … Read more

Washington Social Club

Catching Looks
Badman (2004)

"Move the flipping* Audi [away from the front of the club]!" shouted one of the members of the Washington Social Club to the audience. They drew quite a crowd -including an Audi - for a headlining show at the Black Cat in Washington DC. I was not intrigued at first impression; I was there to see another local band and … Read more

A Day in Black and White/Black Castle

Split
State of Mind (2004)

Splits are ideally awesome, with two bands combining their sounds for one album. Often times though it ends up that one side has a great band while the other has some weakness that jumped on. While Black Castle doesn't have as much to offer as A Day In Black And White, the two forces combined make a decent split. If … Read more

Joan Of Arc

Joan Of Arc, Dick Cheney, Mark Twain
Polyvinyl (2004)

It's strange to think that Tim Kinsella has been at it for about decade now, using his inexplicable charms and off-key personality with groups like Cap'n Jazz, Make Believe, Owls, Friend/Enemy, and his long-standing Joan Of Arc project to create an impressive and utterly distinctive catalog. The man's certainly prolific, releasing at least one new addition to an extensive body … Read more

Set Your Goals

Set Your Goals
Straight On (2004)

Recently, the scene of hardcore-punk has become a stagnant cesspool of monotony. Out of the thousands of bands playing "hardcore" music, there is only a hand-full that have the audacity to do something different. California's melodic punk/hardcore hybrid Set Your Goals is one of those bands and upstart label Straight On Records (The Warriors, Go it Alone) has taken notice. … Read more

Rilo Kiley

More Adventurous
Brute (2004)

It was kind of shocking when Rilo Kiley decided to leave Saddle Creek in pursuit of their own record label, Brute/Beaute. In the whole history of Saddle Creek Records, no one has just decided to leave the label. Ever. Somebody had to do it sooner or later. There are no contracts, so any band can leave with ease. Rilo Kiley … Read more

Cut The Shit

Marked For Life
Gloom (2004)

By the time you read this, Cut The Shit will have already finished their final west coast shows and be on the way to breaking up. Their final show will no doubt be off the hook, but for those of us who won't be able to attend said event, we are blessed with ten and a half minutes of near … Read more

Funeral For a Friend

Casually Dressed & Deep in Conversation
Ferret (2004)

Read more

The Good Life

Album of the Year
Saddle Creek (2004)

Tim Kasher manages to juggle two well-respected bands without taking a noticeable break. The strident noise of Cursive may sound much harsher than the soft melodies of The Good Life, but most of the songs are on the same subject of unsuccessful relationships. The Good Life makes that disappointing love theme into a year-long affair on their third full-length album, … Read more

Reviews by score
Browse our album reviews according to score: Highest (9.5/10 or more) or Lowest (2/10 or less)